Update 8-4-2010 - Primary result
Michigan's 6th District - Congress
Incumbent - Fred Upton (R-St. Joseph)
Years in office as of 2010 election - 24.
Cook District Numbers -EVEN
GOP Candidates - Fred Upton
Dem Candidates - Don Cooney
Barone’s numbers
2008:
Obama - 54%
McCain - 44%
2004:
Bush - 53%
Kerry – 46%
2000
Bush - 52%
Gore - 45%
This district covers all of Berrien, Cass, Kalamazoo, St Joe, and Van Buren Counties. It also covers parts of Allegan and two areas in Calhoun County.
This is a darkhorse district we need to keep an eye on. I mentioned in the 2nd and 3rd districts, the West Michigan blue shift. Three areas most of all have majorly shifted on a consistent level, not just in 2008 (although they did in spades). Kalamazoo County, Grand Rapids, and Muskegon County. Kalamazoo County most of all. It's been blue for a long time (Howard Wolpe won there in the 1980's), although competitive...until recently. Now it is a stronghold for the democrats as the suburbs are also going blue. Van Buren has been competitive for awhile as well (people forget that Clinton won it), and Southern Allegan County is also competitive. Allegan County is Republican because of its northern side, most of which is in Hoekstra's district. Berrien County is split and shifted heavily as well in 08. I think one factor here is Chicago area proximity. This part of Michigan is more tied to Chicago than Detroit. Northwest Indiana had a major blue shift as well in 2008. The other major factor is minorities. Benton Harbor and Benton Township are democrat strongholds in Berrien County. Niles leans democrat as well and has a sizable minority population. The question is this. Is the whole district following Kalamazoo County or is 08 an aberration? I think both. I think Van Buren is following Kalamazoo, but the rest is a partial aberration. My alarm bells are heightened however.
The other thing with Kalamazoo is money. There's some big money leftism here. The Stryer family. Jon Stryker is an uber-radical leftist who runs radical the radical Arcus Foundation. He's also a gazillionaire heir of the Stryker fortune, and will spend his money to harm this state and country with his radical ideas.
Fred Upton is the incumbent and has never had a tough general election. His weakest win was in 1990 under a different district. His weakest in the current district (and 2nd weakest overall) was 2008 with 59% against a sacrificial lamb in Kalamazoo City Councilman Don Cooney. Most of his wins are about 65%. I'll split Berrien and Kalamazoo, as well as the already split counties. Here's the Upton 2008 numbers. Benton Harbor is as democrat as Detroit, and the city and township of Kalamazoo are D strongholds.
| 2008 Election | Upton | Cooney | 3rd Party | Total | Diff. | GOP% | Dem% | Diff% |
| Allegan County | - | 0 | #DIV/0! | #DIV/0! | #DIV/0! | |||
| City of Allegan | 1108 | 846 | 88 | 2,042 | 262 | 54.26% | 41.43% | 12.83% |
| Allegan Twp | 1220 | 730 | 70 | 2,020 | 490 | 60.40% | 36.14% | 24.26% |
| Casco Twp | 826 | 561 | 32 | 1,419 | 265 | 58.21% | 39.53% | 18.68% |
| Cheshire Twp | 574 | 351 | 51 | 976 | 223 | 58.81% | 35.96% | 22.85% |
| Clyde Twp | 430 | 299 | 46 | 775 | 131 | 55.48% | 38.58% | 16.90% |
| Dorr Twp | 1215 | 475 | 63 | 1,753 | 740 | 69.31% | 27.10% | 42.21% |
| Ganges Twp | 822 | 500 | 50 | 1,372 | 322 | 59.91% | 36.44% | 23.47% |
| Gunplain Twp | 1991 | 1045 | 97 | 3,133 | 946 | 63.55% | 33.35% | 30.19% |
| Hopkins Twp | 842 | 362 | 61 | 1,265 | 480 | 66.56% | 28.62% | 37.94% |
| Lee Twp | 530 | 466 | 46 | 1,042 | 64 | 50.86% | 44.72% | 6.14% |
| Leighton Township | 1822 | 472 | 87 | 2,381 | 1350 | 76.52% | 19.82% | 56.70% |
| Martin Twp | 862 | 307 | 28 | 1,197 | 555 | 72.01% | 25.65% | 46.37% |
| City of Otsego | 1024 | 593 | 49 | 1,666 | 431 | 61.46% | 35.59% | 25.87% |
| Otsego Twp | 1654 | 882 | 85 | 2,621 | 772 | 63.11% | 33.65% | 29.45% |
| City of Plainwell | 1007 | 682 | 54 | 1,743 | 325 | 57.77% | 39.13% | 18.65% |
| Trowbridge Twp | 718 | 430 | 53 | 1,201 | 288 | 59.78% | 35.80% | 23.98% |
| Valley Twp | 561 | 339 | 29 | 929 | 222 | 60.39% | 36.49% | 23.90% |
| Watson Twp | 579 | 295 | 42 | 916 | 284 | 63.21% | 32.21% | 31.00% |
| City of Wayland | 995 | 627 | 73 | 1,695 | 368 | 58.70% | 36.99% | 21.71% |
| Wayland Twp | 951 | 510 | 56 | 1,517 | 441 | 62.69% | 33.62% | 29.07% |
| Berrien County | - | 0 | #DIV/0! | #DIV/0! | #DIV/0! | |||
| Bainbridge Twp | 1,071 | 352 | 31 | 1,454 | 719 | 73.66% | 24.21% | 49.45% |
| Baroda Twp | 1,036 | 405 | 38 | 1,479 | 631 | 70.05% | 27.38% | 42.66% |
| City of Benton Harbor | 384 | 3,832 | 108 | 4,324 | -3448 | 8.88% | 88.62% | -79.74% |
| Benton Township | 2,086 | 4,312 | 145 | 6,543 | -2226 | 31.88% | 65.90% | -34.02% |
| Berrien Twp | 1,694 | 548 | 45 | 2,287 | 1146 | 74.07% | 23.96% | 50.11% |
| Bertrand Twp | 996 | 394 | 28 | 1,418 | 602 | 70.24% | 27.79% | 42.45% |
| City of Bridgman | 786 | 373 | 21 | 1,180 | 413 | 66.61% | 31.61% | 35.00% |
| City of Buchanan | 1,058 | 819 | 38 | 1,915 | 239 | 55.25% | 42.77% | 12.48% |
| Buchanan Twp | 1,125 | 543 | 48 | 1,716 | 582 | 65.56% | 31.64% | 33.92% |
| Chikaming Twp | 1,099 | 701 | 41 | 1,841 | 398 | 59.70% | 38.08% | 21.62% |
| City of Coloma | 515 | 213 | 13 | 741 | 302 | 69.50% | 28.74% | 40.76% |
| Coloma Twp | 1,706 | 609 | 60 | 2,375 | 1097 | 71.83% | 25.64% | 46.19% |
| Galien Twp | 393 | 275 | 18 | 686 | 118 | 57.29% | 40.09% | 17.20% |
| Hagar Twp | 1,218 | 552 | 36 | 1,806 | 666 | 67.44% | 30.56% | 36.88% |
| Lake Twp | 1,156 | 479 | 27 | 1,662 | 677 | 69.55% | 28.82% | 40.73% |
| Lincoln Twp | 6,318 | 1,818 | 160 | 8,296 | 4500 | 76.16% | 21.91% | 54.24% |
| City of New Buffalo | 498 | 371 | 27 | 896 | 127 | 55.58% | 41.41% | 14.17% |
| New Buffalo Twp | 717 | 539 | 42 | 1,298 | 178 | 55.24% | 41.53% | 13.71% |
| City of Niles | 2,389 | 2,165 | 101 | 4,655 | 224 | 51.32% | 46.51% | 4.81% |
| Niles Twp | 3,735 | 2,279 | 137 | 6,151 | 1456 | 60.72% | 37.05% | 23.67% |
| Oronoko Twp | 2,307 | 1,210 | 109 | 3,626 | 1097 | 63.62% | 33.37% | 30.25% |
| Pipestone Twp | 771 | 264 | 24 | 1,059 | 507 | 72.80% | 24.93% | 47.88% |
| Royalton Twp | 2,112 | 469 | 61 | 2,642 | 1643 | 79.94% | 17.75% | 62.19% |
| Sodus Twp | 645 | 298 | 34 | 977 | 347 | 66.02% | 30.50% | 35.52% |
| City of St Joseph | 3,269 | 1,235 | 97 | 4,601 | 2034 | 71.05% | 26.84% | 44.21% |
| St Joseph Twp | 4,204 | 1,896 | 127 | 6,227 | 2308 | 67.51% | 30.45% | 37.06% |
| Three Oaks Twp | 807 | 553 | 28 | 1,388 | 254 | 58.14% | 39.84% | 18.30% |
| City of Watervliet | 424 | 229 | 17 | 670 | 195 | 63.28% | 34.18% | 29.10% |
| Watervliet Twp | 872 | 438 | 30 | 1,340 | 434 | 65.07% | 32.69% | 32.39% |
| Weesaw Twp | 616 | 359 | 25 | 1,000 | 257 | 61.60% | 35.90% | 25.70% |
| Calhoun County: | - | 0 | #DIV/0! | #DIV/0! | #DIV/0! | |||
| Athens Twp | 413 | 196 | 27 | 636 | 217 | 64.94% | 30.82% | 34.12% |
| Leroy Twp | 1,438 | 621 | 62 | 2,121 | 817 | 67.80% | 29.28% | 38.52% |
| Cass County | 14,234 | 8,148 | 527 | 22,909 | 6086 | 62.13% | 35.57% | 26.57% |
| Kalamazoo County: | - | 0 | #DIV/0! | #DIV/0! | #DIV/0! | |||
| Alamo Twp | 1,496 | 646 | 47 | 2,189 | 850 | 68.34% | 29.51% | 38.83% |
| Brady Twp | 1,612 | 707 | 75 | 2,394 | 905 | 67.34% | 29.53% | 37.80% |
| Charleston Twp | 688 | 330 | 40 | 1,058 | 358 | 65.03% | 31.19% | 33.84% |
| Climax Twp | 832 | 363 | 37 | 1,232 | 469 | 67.53% | 29.46% | 38.07% |
| Comstock Twp | 4,578 | 2,966 | 207 | 7,751 | 1612 | 59.06% | 38.27% | 20.80% |
| Cooper Twp | 3,324 | 1,996 | 144 | 5,464 | 1328 | 60.83% | 36.53% | 24.30% |
| City of Galesburg | 392 | 290 | 35 | 717 | 102 | 54.67% | 40.45% | 14.23% |
| City of Kalamazoo | 11,312 | 21,108 | 930 | 33,350 | -9796 | 33.92% | 63.29% | -29.37% |
| Kalamazoo Twp | 4,982 | 5,756 | 259 | 10,997 | -774 | 45.30% | 52.34% | -7.04% |
| Oshtemo Twp | 5,862 | 4,738 | 282 | 10,882 | 1124 | 53.87% | 43.54% | 10.33% |
| City of Parchment | 519 | 384 | 19 | 922 | 135 | 56.29% | 41.65% | 14.64% |
| Pavilion Twp | 2,002 | 1,071 | 84 | 3,157 | 931 | 63.41% | 33.92% | 29.49% |
| City of Portage | 15,541 | 8,967 | 446 | 24,954 | 6574 | 62.28% | 35.93% | 26.34% |
| Prairie Ronde Twp | 937 | 327 | 28 | 1,292 | 610 | 72.52% | 25.31% | 47.21% |
| Richland Twp | 2,847 | 1,356 | 105 | 4,308 | 1491 | 66.09% | 31.48% | 34.61% |
| Ross Twp | 2,079 | 859 | 75 | 3,013 | 1220 | 69.00% | 28.51% | 40.49% |
| Schoolcraft Twp | 2,774 | 1,313 | 118 | 4,205 | 1461 | 65.97% | 31.22% | 34.74% |
| Texas Twp | 5,812 | 2,250 | 196 | 8,258 | 3562 | 70.38% | 27.25% | 43.13% |
| Wakeshma Twp | 447 | 176 | 30 | 653 | 271 | 68.45% | 26.95% | 41.50% |
| St Joseph County | 17,676 | 6,925 | 597 | 25,198 | 10751 | 70.15% | 27.48% | 42.67% |
| Van Buren County | 20,628 | 12,461 | 866 | 33,955 | 8167 | 60.75% | 36.70% | 24.05% |
| Total | 188,163 | 123,256 | 8,112 | 319,531 | 64907 | 58.89% | 38.57% | 20.31% |
2004 and 2008 show the shifts.The whole area shifted heavily.
| 2004 Election | Bush | Kerry | 3rd Party | Total | Diff. | GOP% | Dem% | Diff% |
| Allegan County | - | 0 | #DIV/0! | #DIV/0! | #DIV/0! | |||
| City of Allegan | 1035 | 1005 | 30 | 2,070 | 30 | 50.00% | 48.55% | 1.45% |
| Allegan Twp | 1108 | 924 | 20 | 2,052 | 184 | 54.00% | 45.03% | 8.97% |
| Casco Twp | 768 | 673 | 13 | 1,454 | 95 | 52.82% | 46.29% | 6.53% |
| Cheshire Twp | 541 | 475 | 16 | 1,032 | 66 | 52.42% | 46.03% | 6.40% |
| Clyde Twp | 421 | 318 | 10 | 749 | 103 | 56.21% | 42.46% | 13.75% |
| Dorr Twp (3) | 1305 | 522 | 15 | 1,842 | 783 | 70.85% | 28.34% | 42.51% |
| Ganges Twp | 787 | 599 | 27 | 1,413 | 188 | 55.70% | 42.39% | 13.31% |
| Gunplain Twp | 1743 | 1334 | 21 | 3,098 | 409 | 56.26% | 43.06% | 13.20% |
| Hopkins Twp | 871 | 434 | 17 | 1,322 | 437 | 65.89% | 32.83% | 33.06% |
| Lee Twp | 471 | 588 | 12 | 1,071 | -117 | 43.98% | 54.90% | -10.92% |
| Leighton Township | 1802 | 490 | 16 | 2,308 | 1312 | 78.08% | 21.23% | 56.85% |
| Martin Twp | 832 | 355 | 6 | 1,193 | 477 | 69.74% | 29.76% | 39.98% |
| City of Otsego | 892 | 862 | 18 | 1,772 | 30 | 50.34% | 48.65% | 1.69% |
| Otsego Twp | 1375 | 1124 | 18 | 2,517 | 251 | 54.63% | 44.66% | 9.97% |
| City of Plainwell | 919 | 881 | 17 | 1,817 | 38 | 50.58% | 48.49% | 2.09% |
| Trowbridge Twp | 712 | 557 | 11 | 1,280 | 155 | 55.63% | 43.52% | 12.11% |
| Valley Twp | 540 | 424 | 13 | 977 | 116 | 55.27% | 43.40% | 11.87% |
| Watson Twp | 550 | 379 | 12 | 941 | 171 | 58.45% | 40.28% | 18.17% |
| City of Wayland | 1096 | 709 | 30 | 1,835 | 387 | 59.73% | 38.64% | 21.09% |
| Wayland Twp | 973 | 614 | 13 | 1,600 | 359 | 60.81% | 38.38% | 22.44% |
| Berrien County | - | 0 | #DIV/0! | #DIV/0! | #DIV/0! | |||
| Bainbridge Twp | 1,016 | 394 | 15 | 1,425 | 622 | 71.30% | 27.65% | 43.65% |
| Baroda Twp | 969 | 474 | 15 | 1,458 | 495 | 66.46% | 32.51% | 33.95% |
| City of Benton Harbor | 161 | 3,600 | 17 | 3,778 | -3439 | 4.26% | 95.29% | -91.03% |
| Benton Township | 1,739 | 4,123 | 37 | 5,899 | -2384 | 29.48% | 69.89% | -40.41% |
| Berrien Twp | 1,552 | 708 | 26 | 2,286 | 844 | 67.89% | 30.97% | 36.92% |
| Bertrand Twp | 799 | 541 | 17 | 1,357 | 258 | 58.88% | 39.87% | 19.01% |
| City of Bridgman | 772 | 427 | 17 | 1,216 | 345 | 63.49% | 35.12% | 28.37% |
| City of Buchanan | 1,005 | 958 | 12 | 1,975 | 47 | 50.89% | 48.51% | 2.38% |
| Buchanan Twp | 1,014 | 741 | 25 | 1,780 | 273 | 56.97% | 41.63% | 15.34% |
| Chikaming Twp | 1,124 | 842 | 17 | 1,983 | 282 | 56.68% | 42.46% | 14.22% |
| City of Coloma | 444 | 308 | 8 | 760 | 136 | 58.42% | 40.53% | 17.89% |
| Coloma Twp | 1,573 | 829 | 22 | 2,424 | 744 | 64.89% | 34.20% | 30.69% |
| Galien Twp | 376 | 334 | 11 | 721 | 42 | 52.15% | 46.32% | 5.83% |
| Hagar Twp | 1,146 | 671 | 19 | 1,836 | 475 | 62.42% | 36.55% | 25.87% |
| Lake Twp | 1,098 | 594 | 25 | 1,717 | 504 | 63.95% | 34.60% | 29.35% |
| Lincoln Twp | 5,646 | 2,474 | 87 | 8,207 | 3172 | 68.79% | 30.14% | 38.65% |
| City of New Buffalo | 474 | 451 | 16 | 941 | 23 | 50.37% | 47.93% | 2.44% |
| New Buffalo Twp | 624 | 675 | 8 | 1,307 | -51 | 47.74% | 51.64% | -3.90% |
| City of Niles | 2,145 | 2,426 | 43 | 4,614 | -281 | 46.49% | 52.58% | -6.09% |
| Niles Twp | 3,210 | 2,705 | 55 | 5,970 | 505 | 53.77% | 45.31% | 8.46% |
| Oronoko Twp | 2,057 | 1,310 | 63 | 3,430 | 747 | 59.97% | 38.19% | 21.78% |
| Pipestone Twp | 724 | 330 | 13 | 1,067 | 394 | 67.85% | 30.93% | 36.93% |
| Royalton Twp | 1,717 | 661 | 22 | 2,400 | 1056 | 71.54% | 27.54% | 44.00% |
| Sodus Twp | 566 | 344 | 13 | 923 | 222 | 61.32% | 37.27% | 24.05% |
| City of St Joseph | 2,630 | 1,865 | 49 | 4,544 | 765 | 57.88% | 41.04% | 16.84% |
| St Joseph Twp | 3,808 | 2,326 | 37 | 6,171 | 1482 | 61.71% | 37.69% | 24.02% |
| Three Oaks Twp | 826 | 583 | 9 | 1,418 | 243 | 58.25% | 41.11% | 17.14% |
| City of Watervliet | 418 | 270 | 8 | 696 | 148 | 60.06% | 38.79% | 21.26% |
| Watervliet Twp | 826 | 513 | 8 | 1,347 | 313 | 61.32% | 38.08% | 23.24% |
| Weesaw Twp | 617 | 369 | 20 | 1,006 | 248 | 61.33% | 36.68% | 24.65% |
| Calhoun County: | - | 0 | #DIV/0! | #DIV/0! | #DIV/0! | |||
| Athens Twp | 784 | 499 | 9 | 1,292 | 285 | 60.68% | 38.62% | 22.06% |
| Leroy Twp | 1,297 | 773 | 11 | 2,081 | 524 | 62.33% | 37.15% | 25.18% |
| Cass County | 12,964 | 9,537 | 196 | 22,697 | 3427 | 57.12% | 42.02% | 15.10% |
| Kalamazoo County: | - | 0 | #DIV/0! | #DIV/0! | #DIV/0! | |||
| Alamo Twp | 1,288 | 918 | 20 | 2,226 | 370 | 57.86% | 41.24% | 16.62% |
| Brady Twp | 1,411 | 991 | 15 | 2,417 | 420 | 58.38% | 41.00% | 17.38% |
| Charleston Twp | 592 | 419 | 15 | 1,026 | 173 | 57.70% | 40.84% | 16.86% |
| Climax Twp | 757 | 509 | 15 | 1,281 | 248 | 59.09% | 39.73% | 19.36% |
| Comstock Twp | 3,844 | 3,734 | 59 | 7,637 | 110 | 50.33% | 48.89% | 1.44% |
| Cooper Twp | 2,825 | 2,462 | 49 | 5,336 | 363 | 52.94% | 46.14% | 6.80% |
| City of Galesburg | 365 | 372 | 10 | 747 | -7 | 48.86% | 49.80% | -0.94% |
| City of Kalamazoo | 9,378 | 19,377 | 337 | 29,092 | -9999 | 32.24% | 66.61% | -34.37% |
| Kalamazoo Twp | 4,405 | 6,165 | 108 | 10,678 | -1760 | 41.25% | 57.74% | -16.48% |
| Oshtemo Twp | 4,703 | 4,850 | 103 | 9,656 | -147 | 48.71% | 50.23% | -1.52% |
| City of Parchment | 516 | 482 | 7 | 1,005 | 34 | 51.34% | 47.96% | 3.38% |
| Pavilion Twp | 1,643 | 1,412 | 31 | 3,086 | 231 | 53.24% | 45.76% | 7.49% |
| City of Portage | 13,115 | 11,597 | 213 | 24,925 | 1518 | 52.62% | 46.53% | 6.09% |
| Prairie Ronde Twp | 848 | 458 | 5 | 1,311 | 390 | 64.68% | 34.94% | 29.75% |
| Richland Twp | 2,354 | 1,710 | 51 | 4,115 | 644 | 57.21% | 41.56% | 15.65% |
| Ross Twp | 1,900 | 1,197 | 25 | 3,122 | 703 | 60.86% | 38.34% | 22.52% |
| Schoolcraft Twp | 2,288 | 1,652 | 41 | 3,981 | 636 | 57.47% | 41.50% | 15.98% |
| Texas Twp | 4,509 | 2,919 | 29 | 7,457 | 1590 | 60.47% | 39.14% | 21.32% |
| Wakeshma Twp | 406 | 220 | 12 | 638 | 186 | 63.64% | 34.48% | 29.15% |
| St Joseph County | 15,340 | 9,648 | 251 | 25,239 | 5692 | 60.78% | 38.23% | 22.55% |
| Van Buren County | 17,634 | 16,151 | 389 | 34,174 | 1483 | 51.60% | 47.26% | 4.34% |
| Total | 164,983 | 144,165 | 3,070 | 312,218 | 20818 | 52.84% | 46.17% | 6.67% |
2004 wasn't bad, although the dems made big gains in Kalamazoo over 2000. The rest of the area moved to the right. In 2008, it was a professional ass kicking going the other way.
| 2008 election | McCain | Obama | 3rd Party | Total | Diff. | GOP% | Dem% | Diff% |
| Allegan County | - | 0 | #DIV/0! | #DIV/0! | #DIV/0! | |||
| City of Allegan | 845 | 1212 | 43 | 2,100 | -367 | 40.24% | 57.71% | -17.48% |
| Allegan Twp | 946 | 1114 | 42 | 2,102 | -168 | 45.00% | 53.00% | -7.99% |
| Casco Twp | 636 | 792 | 20 | 1,448 | -156 | 43.92% | 54.70% | -10.77% |
| Cheshire Twp | 456 | 524 | 29 | 1,009 | -68 | 45.19% | 51.93% | -6.74% |
| Clyde Twp | 359 | 446 | 18 | 823 | -87 | 43.62% | 54.19% | -10.57% |
| Dorr Twp (3/4) | 1165 | 632 | 46 | 1,843 | 533 | 63.21% | 34.29% | 28.92% |
| Ganges Twp | 662 | 708 | 36 | 1,406 | -46 | 47.08% | 50.36% | -3.27% |
| Gunplain Twp | 1520 | 1621 | 67 | 3,208 | -101 | 47.38% | 50.53% | -3.15% |
| Hopkins Twp | 770 | 514 | 33 | 1,317 | 256 | 58.47% | 39.03% | 19.44% |
| Lee Twp | 428 | 635 | 17 | 1,080 | -207 | 39.63% | 58.80% | -19.17% |
| Leighton Township | 1739 | 681 | 43 | 2,463 | 1058 | 70.60% | 27.65% | 42.96% |
| Martin Twp | 761 | 455 | 17 | 1,233 | 306 | 61.72% | 36.90% | 24.82% |
| City of Otsego | 711 | 982 | 34 | 1,727 | -271 | 41.17% | 56.86% | -15.69% |
| Otsego Twp | 1217 | 1433 | 58 | 2,708 | -216 | 44.94% | 52.92% | -7.98% |
| City of Plainwell | 731 | 1035 | 33 | 1,799 | -304 | 40.63% | 57.53% | -16.90% |
| Trowbridge Twp | 575 | 623 | 30 | 1,228 | -48 | 46.82% | 50.73% | -3.91% |
| Valley Twp | 442 | 516 | 15 | 973 | -74 | 45.43% | 53.03% | -7.61% |
| Watson Twp | 470 | 447 | 21 | 938 | 23 | 50.11% | 47.65% | 2.45% |
| City of Wayland | 883 | 843 | 38 | 1,764 | 40 | 50.06% | 47.79% | 2.27% |
| Wayland Twp | 838 | 725 | 33 | 1,596 | 113 | 52.51% | 45.43% | 7.08% |
| Berrien County | - | 0 | #DIV/0! | #DIV/0! | #DIV/0! | |||
| Bainbridge Twp | 926 | 519 | 22 | 1,467 | 407 | 63.12% | 35.38% | 27.74% |
| Baroda Twp | 851 | 614 | 31 | 1,496 | 237 | 56.89% | 41.04% | 15.84% |
| City of Benton Harbor | 94 | 4,364 | 3 | 4,461 | -4270 | 2.11% | 97.83% | -95.72% |
| Benton Township | 1,480 | 5,108 | 59 | 6,647 | -3628 | 22.27% | 76.85% | -54.58% |
| Berrien Twp | 1,398 | 903 | 43 | 2,344 | 495 | 59.64% | 38.52% | 21.12% |
| Bertrand Twp | 776 | 642 | 26 | 1,444 | 134 | 53.74% | 44.46% | 9.28% |
| City of Bridgman | 625 | 555 | 21 | 1,201 | 70 | 52.04% | 46.21% | 5.83% |
| City of Buchanan | 792 | 1,140 | 27 | 1,959 | -348 | 40.43% | 58.19% | -17.76% |
| Buchanan Twp | 895 | 794 | 43 | 1,732 | 101 | 51.67% | 45.84% | 5.83% |
| Chikaming Twp | 907 | 950 | 23 | 1,880 | -43 | 48.24% | 50.53% | -2.29% |
| City of Coloma | 412 | 327 | 18 | 757 | 85 | 54.43% | 43.20% | 11.23% |
| Coloma Twp | 1,437 | 949 | 39 | 2,425 | 488 | 59.26% | 39.13% | 20.12% |
| Galien Twp | 312 | 381 | 11 | 704 | -69 | 44.32% | 54.12% | -9.80% |
| Hagar Twp | 992 | 805 | 22 | 1,819 | 187 | 54.54% | 44.26% | 10.28% |
| Lake Twp | 943 | 715 | 37 | 1,695 | 228 | 55.63% | 42.18% | 13.45% |
| Lincoln Twp | 5,112 | 3,165 | 105 | 8,382 | 1947 | 60.99% | 37.76% | 23.23% |
| City of New Buffalo | 390 | 504 | 16 | 910 | -114 | 42.86% | 55.38% | -12.53% |
| New Buffalo Twp | 591 | 739 | 26 | 1,356 | -148 | 43.58% | 54.50% | -10.91% |
| City of Niles | 1,712 | 2,976 | 98 | 4,786 | -1264 | 35.77% | 62.18% | -26.41% |
| Niles Twp | 2,906 | 3,301 | 102 | 6,309 | -395 | 46.06% | 52.32% | -6.26% |
| Oronoko Twp | 1,794 | 1,858 | 73 | 3,725 | -64 | 48.16% | 49.88% | -1.72% |
| Pipestone Twp | 662 | 395 | 24 | 1,081 | 267 | 61.24% | 36.54% | 24.70% |
| Royalton Twp | 1,743 | 886 | 38 | 2,667 | 857 | 65.35% | 33.22% | 32.13% |
| Sodus Twp | 559 | 411 | 21 | 991 | 148 | 56.41% | 41.47% | 14.93% |
| City of St Joseph | 2,331 | 2,253 | 55 | 4,639 | 78 | 50.25% | 48.57% | 1.68% |
| St Joseph Twp | 3,240 | 2,975 | 89 | 6,304 | 265 | 51.40% | 47.19% | 4.20% |
| Three Oaks Twp | 627 | 770 | 24 | 1,421 | -143 | 44.12% | 54.19% | -10.06% |
| City of Watervliet | 332 | 339 | 9 | 680 | -7 | 48.82% | 49.85% | -1.03% |
| Watervliet Twp | 751 | 589 | 20 | 1,360 | 162 | 55.22% | 43.31% | 11.91% |
| Weesaw Twp | 540 | 454 | 27 | 1,021 | 86 | 52.89% | 44.47% | 8.42% |
| Calhoun County: | - | 0 | #DIV/0! | #DIV/0! | #DIV/0! | |||
| Athens Twp | 660 | 564 | 33 | 1,257 | 96 | 52.51% | 44.87% | 7.64% |
| Leroy Twp | 1,289 | 885 | 30 | 2,204 | 404 | 58.48% | 40.15% | 18.33% |
| Cass County | 11,114 | 12,083 | 379 | 23,576 | -969 | 47.14% | 51.25% | -4.11% |
| Kalamazoo County: | - | 0 | #DIV/0! | #DIV/0! | #DIV/0! | |||
| Alamo Twp | 1,198 | 1,049 | 33 | 2,280 | 149 | 52.54% | 46.01% | 6.54% |
| Brady Twp | 1,290 | 1,101 | 60 | 2,451 | 189 | 52.63% | 44.92% | 7.71% |
| Charleston Twp | 589 | 457 | 41 | 1,087 | 132 | 54.19% | 42.04% | 12.14% |
| Climax Twp | 728 | 524 | 28 | 1,280 | 204 | 56.88% | 40.94% | 15.94% |
| Comstock Twp | 3,564 | 4,289 | 134 | 7,987 | -725 | 44.62% | 53.70% | -9.08% |
| Cooper Twp | 2,635 | 2,873 | 110 | 5,618 | -238 | 46.90% | 51.14% | -4.24% |
| City of Galesburg | 280 | 442 | 14 | 736 | -162 | 38.04% | 60.05% | -22.01% |
| City of Kalamazoo | 8,069 | 25,823 | 582 | 34,474 | -17754 | 23.41% | 74.91% | -51.50% |
| Kalamazoo Twp | 3,653 | 7,469 | 185 | 11,307 | -3816 | 32.31% | 66.06% | -33.75% |
| Oshtemo Twp | 4,414 | 6,565 | 204 | 11,183 | -2151 | 39.47% | 58.71% | -19.23% |
| City of Parchment | 416 | 516 | 15 | 947 | -100 | 43.93% | 54.49% | -10.56% |
| Pavilion Twp | 1,556 | 1,632 | 55 | 3,243 | -76 | 47.98% | 50.32% | -2.34% |
| City of Portage | 11,448 | 14,049 | 363 | 25,860 | -2601 | 44.27% | 54.33% | -10.06% |
| Prairie Ronde Twp | 770 | 538 | 16 | 1,324 | 232 | 58.16% | 40.63% | 17.52% |
| Richland Twp | 2,261 | 2,108 | 61 | 4,430 | 153 | 51.04% | 47.58% | 3.45% |
| Ross Twp | 1,651 | 1,386 | 41 | 3,078 | 265 | 53.64% | 45.03% | 8.61% |
| Schoolcraft Twp | 2,164 | 2,071 | 65 | 4,300 | 93 | 50.33% | 48.16% | 2.16% |
| Texas Twp | 4,469 | 3,864 | 135 | 8,468 | 605 | 52.78% | 45.63% | 7.14% |
| Wakeshma Twp | 399 | 265 | 14 | 678 | 134 | 58.85% | 39.09% | 19.76% |
| St Joseph County | 12,886 | 12,322 | 494 | 25,702 | 564 | 50.14% | 47.94% | 2.19% |
| Van Buren County | 15,534 | 18,588 | 644 | 34,766 | -3054 | 44.68% | 53.47% | -8.78% |
| Total | 145,321 | 177,782 | 5,561 | 328,664 | -32461 | 44.22% | 54.09% | -9.88% |
Dems gain 8%. GOP drops 9%. This was the 3rd biggest swing in the state. The 3rd was the biggest swing, and the 2nd was the 2nd biggest swing. I think part of it was the Chicago and South Bend influence, Kalamazoo influence, McCain quitting the state and announcing it, and also the economy.
Breaking down the numbers a bit.
Allegan County: Southern Allegan took a heavy democrat swing. If it wasn't for Dorr Twp, it would have flipped.
2004 - Bush 57.94%, Kerry 41.02%. 32343 votes, 5474 vote spread
2008 - McCain 49.30%, Obama 48.64%, 32765 votes, 216 vote spread
Berrien County swing the same way. I took out Benton Harbor and Twp and separated them. Niles really shifted. The difference in the Bentons was more turnout.
Benton Harbor/Twp
2004 - Kerry 79.81%, Bush 19.63%, 9677 votes, -5823 vote spread
2008 - Obama 85.27%, McCain 14.17%, 11108 votes, -7898 vote spread
Rest of County
2004 - Bush 60.29%, Kerry 38.66%, 64,979 votes, 14053 vote spread
2008 - McCain 51.92%, Obama 46.44%, 66555 votes, 3647 vote spread
Cass County followed the West Michigan pattern. I think the sizable rural minority vote here factored as well. Dowagiac and Vandalia kept it from being a stronghold for the GOP, although Bush did very well in 2004 (less so in 2000).
2004 - Bush 57.12%, Kerry 42.02%, 22,697 votes, 3427 vote spread
2008 - Obama 51.25%, McCain 47.14%, 23576 votes, -969 vote spread.
Van Buren County has always been more competitive. Clinton won it. Gore almost did. Covert (stronghold) and South Haven are democrat leaning. The rest of the county is not that republican.
2004 - Bush 51.60%, Kerry 47.26%, 34,174 votes, 1483 vote spread
2008 - Obama 53.47%, McCain 44.68%, 34,766 votes, -3054 vote spread
St Joe County - Stayed in the fold, but should not be close.
2004 - Bush 60.78%, Kerry 38.23%, 25239 votes, 5692 vote spread.
2008 - McCain 50.14%, Obama 47.94%, 25702 votes, 564 vote spread
Calhoun County - Only two townships, and they are very strongly GOP.
2004 - Bush 61.70%, Kerry 37.71%, 3373 votes, 809 vote spread
2008 - McCain 56.31%, Obama 41.87%, 3461 votes, 500 vote spread
Kalamazoo County is becoming a major stronghold for the democrats. Two areas of influence dominate the City of Kalamazoo. The north side and part of the east side which is mostly black, and Western Michigan University on the west side. I separated this three ways. The city itself, close in burbs, and the outer portions.
City of Kalamazoo (notice the turnout difference here compared to elsewhere) This is the democrats anchor in the district.
2004 - Kerry 66.61%, Bush 32.24%, 29092 votes, -9999 vote spread
2008 - Obama 74.91%, McCain 23.41%, 34,474 votes, -17754 vote spread.
Suburbs (Kzoo Twp, Oshtemo Twp, Portage, Parchment, Comstock, Cooper) Oshtemo (next to WMU) went for Bush in 2000, but Kerry in 04. Comstock and Parchment (away from the University) went the other way. Cooper and Portage vote for Bush twice, and then Obama. Kzoo twp is a democrat stronghold which borders Kalamazoo's black north side. All of them moved toward Obama.
2004 - Bush 49.64%, Kerry 49.45%, 59237 votes, 118 vote spread.
2008 - Obama 56.85%, McCain 41.54%, 62902 votes, -9631 vote spread
Rest of County - Moved towards Obama, but not like the burbs.
2004 - Bush 58.46%, Kerry 40.68%, 31407 votes, 5584 vote spread.
2008 - McCain 52.03%, Obama 46.28%, 33355 votes, 1918 votes
The farm club is heavily republican outside of Kalamazoo City, although there were a couple of very competitive races. I expect a lot of offense here by the dems.
St Senate 24th - Covers Allegan, Barry, and Eaton Counties. Part of Allegan is in the 6th district. It's a solid GOP district, although Eaton County is becoming more and more Lansing influenced.This is an open seat with Patti Birkholz termed out.
| St Senate 24th | GOP | Dem | 3rd Party | Total | Diff. | GOP% | Dem% | Diff% |
| 06 - Birkholz/Royston | 64,737 | 46,480 | 111,217 | 18257 | 58.21% | 41.79% | 16.42% | |
| 02 - Birkholz/Birdson | 57,906 | 32,170 | 90,076 | 25736 | 64.29% | 35.71% | 28.57% |
State Senate 21st - Covers Berrien, Cass, and most of Van Buren Counties (outside of Paw Paw/Antwerp). Ron Jelinek is termed out after two terms as state senator. This COULD be a sleeper, but if we can't win Berrien County, it's going to be a real long night.
| St Senate 21st | GOP | Dem | ||||||
| 06 - Jelinek/Janowski | 50,182 | 36,078 | 86,260 | 14104 | 58.18% | 41.82% | 16.35% | |
| 02 - Jelinek/Toy | 43,239 | 23,473 | 66,712 | 19766 | 64.81% | 35.19% | 29.63% |
St Senate 20th - Covers all of Kalamazoo County, and Antwerp and Paw Paw townships in Van Buren County. Tom George is termed out, after a very competitive 2006 race against Sandy Lipsey. I think this one could be favored democrat, but I think most thought Tom George was toast in 2006, and that didn't happen.
| St Senate 20th | GOP | Dem | ||||||
| 06 - George/Lipsey | 51,553 | 48,353 | 99,906 | 3200 | 51.60% | 48.40% | 3.20% | |
| 02 - George/LaForge | 44,672 | 34,327 | 78,999 | 10345 | 56.55% | 43.45% | 13.10% |
St Senate 19th - Covers all of Calhoun and most of Jackson County - 95% of this district is in the 7th, including the current and previous representatives, both from Battle Creek. Mike Nofs won this in the recent special election replacing Mark Schauer who is now congresscitter.
| St Senate 19th | GOP | Dem | 3rd Party | |||||
| 09 - Nofs/Griffin | 20327 | 11385 | 1543 | 33,255 | 8942 | 61.12% | 34.24% | 26.89% |
| 06 - Schauer/Fulton | 32078 | 50612 | 82,690 | -18534 | 38.79% | 61.21% | -22.41% | |
| 02 - Schauer/Mortimer | 32,281 | 39,673 | 71,954 | -7392 | 44.86% | 55.14% | -10.27% | |
St Senate 16th - Covers Lenawee Branch, Hillsdale, and St Joseph Counties. - Most of this district outside of St Joe is also in the 7th district. This is a generally solid GOP district, but one of the Spades is running for this seat. That will make this more competitive than it otherwise would have been. Dudley lost bad in 02, but won his county, and now has three terms as rep. Don't sleep on this one, despite the 60%+ numbers.
| St Senate 16th | GOP | Dem | 3rd Party | |||||
| 06 - Brown/Christner | 52,699 | 28,128 | 80,827 | 24571 | 65.20% | 34.80% | 30.40% | |
| 02 - Brown/Spade | 39894 | 25604 | 65,498 | 14290 | 60.91% | 39.09% | 21.82% | |
St Rep 88th - Covers most of Allegan County - Solidly GOP, as it has all of the 2nd district's portion of Allegan County.
| St Rep 88th | GOP | Dem | 3rd Party | Total | Diff. | GOP% | Dem% | Diff% |
| 08 - Genetski/Clark | 29,064 | 18,119 | 47,183 | 10945 | 61.60% | 38.40% | 23.20% | |
| 06 - Sheen/Weichman | 24,831 | 14,484 | 1043 | 40,358 | 10347 | 61.53% | 35.89% | 25.64% |
| 04 - Sheen/Fleser | 31,300 | 15,282 | 46,582 | 16018 | 67.19% | 32.81% | 34.39% | |
| 02 - Sheen/Fleser | 20,727 | 9,497 | 30,224 | 11230 | 68.58% | 31.42% | 37.16% |
St Rep 80th - Covers all of Van Buren County and Watson Twp, Otsego City and Township in Allegan County. Tonya Schuitmaker is termed out and this will be a likely competitive open seat, despite the 60%+ numbers.
| St Rep 80th | GOP | Dem | 3rd Party | Total | Diff. | GOP% | Dem% | Diff% |
| 08 - Schuitmaker/Olson | 23,425 | 14,936 | 38,361 | 8489 | 61.06% | 38.94% | 22.13% | |
| 06 - Schuitmaker/Olson | 18,264 | 11,440 | 29,704 | 6824 | 61.49% | 38.51% | 22.97% | |
| 04 - Schuitmaker/Toy | 21,610 | 15,459 | 37,069 | 6151 | 58.30% | 41.70% | 16.59% | |
| 02 - Middaugh/Wolcott | 15,740 | 7,368 | 23,108 | 8372 | 68.11% | 31.89% | 36.23% |
St. Rep 79th - Covers Bainbridge Twp, Benton Harbor, City of Benton Twp, City of Bridgman, City of Coloma, Coloma Twp, Hagar Twp, Lake Twp, Lincoln Twp, Royalton Twp, Sodus Twp, City and Twp of St Joseph, City and Twp of Watervliet. Despite Benton Harbor, this should stay ours, even in an open seat. Niles, Buchanan, and New Buffalo are all in the other seat.
| St Rep 79th | GOP | Dem | 3rd Party | Total | Diff. | GOP% | Dem% | Diff% |
| 08 - Proos/Hahn | 25,441 | 18,969 | 44,410 | 6472 | 57.29% | 42.71% | 14.57% | |
| 06 - Proos/King | 19,660 | 10,576 | 30,236 | 9084 | 65.02% | 34.98% | 30.04% | |
| 04 - Proos/Tobias | 26,377 | 15,703 | 42,080 | 10674 | 62.68% | 37.32% | 25.37% | |
| 02 - LaSata/Haralson | 16,275 | 7,224 | 23,499 | 9051 | 69.26% | 30.74% | 38.52% |
St Rep 78th - Covers Barota Twp, Berrien Twp, Bertrand Twp, Buchanan City and Twp, Chikaming Twp, Galien Twp, New Buffalo City and Twp, Niles City and Twp, Oronoko Twp, Pipestone Twp, Three Oaks Twp, and Weesaw Twp in Berrien County. Covers City of Dowagiac, Howard Twp, Silver Creek Twp, and Wayne Twp in Cass County. Sharon Tyler won an open seat in 2008 narrowly in a democrat year.This district has been somewhat competitive for awhile.
| St Rep 78th | GOP | Dem | 3rd Party | Total | Diff. | GOP% | Dem% | Diff% |
| 08 - Tyler/Truesdall | 20,288 | 18,627 | 38,915 | 1661 | 52.13% | 47.87% | 4.27% | |
| 06 - Nitz/Truesdall | 14,037 | 13,052 | 27,089 | 985 | 51.82% | 48.18% | 3.64% | |
| 04 - Nitz/Gordon | 21,884 | 15,434 | 37,318 | 6450 | 58.64% | 41.36% | 17.28% | |
| 02 - Nitz/Gordon | 11,814 | 8,497 | 20,311 | 3317 | 58.17% | 41.83% | 16.33% |
St Rep 63rd - Covers one precint in Battle Creek, Bedford Twp, Emmett Twp, Marshall City and Twp, Newton Twp, and Pennfield Twp in Calhoun County. Covers Brady Twp, Charleston Twp, Climax Twp, Comstock Twp, City of Galesburg, Pavilion Twp, Richland Twp, Ross Twp, Schoolcraft Twp, and Wakeshma Twp in Kalamazoo County.This is a lean GOP, but not solid GOP district.
| St Rep 63rd | GOP | Dem | 3rd Party | Total | Diff. | GOP% | Dem% | Diff% |
| 08 - Bolger/Smith | 27,641 | 21,188 | 48,829 | 6453 | 56.61% | 43.39% | 13.22% | |
| 06 - Wenke/Smith | 21,263 | 17,352 | 38,615 | 3911 | 55.06% | 44.94% | 10.13% | |
| 04 - Wenke/Geary | 28,181 | 19,723 | 47,904 | 8458 | 58.83% | 41.17% | 17.66% | |
| 02 - Wenke/Mackinder | 18,093 | 13,918 | 32,011 | 4175 | 56.52% | 43.48% | 13.04% |
St Rep 62nd - Covers most of Calhoun County. Only Leroy and Athens Twp is in this district. The rest is in the 7th District.This seat leans slightly democrat, although Nofs held it for three terms. Mark Schauer had it before him, and I believe a GOP'er had it before Mark Schauer. This seat can be competitive.
| St Rep 62nd | GOP | Dem | 3rd Party | Total | Diff. | GOP% | Dem% | Diff% |
| 08 - Moore/Segal | 15,426 | 25,029 | 40,455 | -9603 | 38.13% | 61.87% | -23.74% | |
| 06 - Nofs/Haley | 15,639 | 13,533 | 29,172 | 2106 | 53.61% | 46.39% | 7.22% | |
| 04 - Nofs/Haley | 20,935 | 18,289 | 39,224 | 2646 | 53.37% | 46.63% | 6.75% | |
| 02 - Nofs/Dearing | 13,619 | 11,986 | 25,605 | 1633 | 53.19% | 46.81% | 6.38% |
St Rep 61st - Covers Alamo Twp, part of Kalamazoo Twp, Oshtemo Twp, City of Parchment, City of Portage, Prairie Ronde Twp, and Texas Twp in Kalamazoo County. This is a opening swing district.. Larry DeShazor won the district in an open seat race in 2008. He's running for St Senate. As Portage goes, so does the district. Oshtemo and Kalamazoo Twp made this district dangerous every election.
| St Rep 61st | GOP | Dem | 3rd Party | Total | Diff. | GOP% | Dem% | Diff% |
| 08 - DeShazor/Rogers | 28,307 | 27,123 | 55,430 | 1184 | 51.07% | 48.93% | 2.14% | |
| 08 - Hoogendyk/Rogers | 21,072 | 20,598 | 41,670 | 474 | 50.57% | 49.43% | 1.14% | |
| 04 - Hoogendyk/Houston | 28,167 | 23,150 | 51,317 | 5017 | 54.89% | 45.11% | 9.78% | |
| 02 - Hoogendyk/Houston | 18,720 | 14,398 | 33,118 | 4322 | 56.53% | 43.47% | 13.05% |
St Rep 60th - Covers Kalamazoo City and part of Kalamazoo Twp. Solidly Democrat. Robert Jones is the current rep. Sandy Lipsey was there before him. Ed Laforge before him.
| St Rep 60th | GOP | Dem | 3rd Party | Total | Diff. | GOP% | Dem% | Diff% |
| 08 - Ybema/Jones | 10,663 | 30,149 | 40,812 | -19486 | 26.13% | 73.87% | -47.75% | |
| 06 - Romero/Jones | 7,820 | 18,932 | 26,752 | -11112 | 29.23% | 70.77% | -41.54% | |
| 04 - Fedesna/Lipsey | 11,266 | 24,473 | 35,739 | -13207 | 31.52% | 68.48% | -36.95% | |
| 02 - Liddle/Lipsey | 7,687 | 13,671 | 21,358 | -5984 | 35.99% | 64.01% | -28.02% |
St Rep 59th - Covers most of Cass and all of St Joe County. Matt Lori won the open seat in 2008. This is probably the most republican district in the 6th District area outside of the Allegan seat.
| St Rep 59th | GOP | Dem | 3rd Party | Total | Diff. | GOP% | Dem% | Diff% |
| 08 - Lori/Higgins | 23,844 | 15,980 | 39,824 | 7864 | 59.87% | 40.13% | 19.75% | |
| 06 - Shaffer/Pawlowski | 19,028 | 9,803 | 28,831 | 9225 | 66.00% | 34.00% | 32.00% | |
| 04 - Shaffer/Pawlowski | 27,044 | 11,211 | 38,255 | 15833 | 70.69% | 29.31% | 41.39% | |
| 02 - Shaffer/Beauchamp | 15,227 | 7,432 | 22,659 | 7795 | 67.20% | 32.80% | 34.40% |
The 6th District is the most competitive one in West Michigan. It is one that will be fought hard if Upton retires or runs for state office. The competitiveness is shown in the state senate and state rep races in this district, especially the Kalamazoo suburbs and the Niles area state rep seat. It is imperative that the GOP stops the bleeding the Kalamazoo suburbs, or there will be some headaches out there way in statewide races, and in state rep/senate districts in the area. The Portage/Oshtemo seat will be a barnburner once again, as will the Kalamazoo County State Senate race. These will be ones to watch in 2010.
Updated 5-18-2010 - Jack Hoogendyk is taking on Upton in the primary. This could be interesting. Upton swings left at times, but unlike bigmouth Joe Schwarz, he doesn't have the same arrogance factor that costs him. Upton is a somewhat liberal republican, but he's not shown himself to be a RINO like Schwarz, Crist, Chafee, or Specter. Upton took out Dale Shugars in his last major primary challenge.
Hoogendyk is a big stronger and has a strong grassroots support network. Can he beat Upton? Possible, but it won't be easy. If he beats Upton, can he beat Cooney? Probably. Jack's state rep district was the critical swing district in Kalamazoo County, and he won there three times, including one where he was expected by many to lose.
This will be one to watch in August.


9 comments:
One quick thing to think about his how this district is probably going to change come redistricting. Should the Dems control even just the house, my guess is that this seat will not be as friendly to Upton as its current incarnation.
The same goes for the State House and Senate Seats. If the Dems control both chambers, I could easily see the 61st made into a stronger Democratic district, and the two Berrien County seats could likewise be made into something much more viable for various candidates.
If redistricting is split control, which is what I expect to happen, I think there will likely be an incumbent protection map assuming everyone is re-elected. I think Upton and Schauer would help each other out. Trade Kalamazoo for Coldwater and Hillsdale, and maybe Lenawee. The dems probably want to protect Schauer and to a lesser extent Peters. Schauer's seat will probably get either Kalamazoo, Lansing, or Ann Arbor. Peters will probably get Southfield unless they move the Detroit seats there (Voting Rights Act), otherwise Peters will probably get what I call Ann Arbor East - Huntington Woods, Ferndale, Pleasant Ridge, etc.
If I was redistricting the DeShazor seat, I'd try and give all of K-zoo twp to Jones if possible (I think Kzoo city lost population). If not, I'd try and get Oshtemo (and Alamo) to the Bolger District, and make it a southern county district. All the dems would have to do is take out Texas Twp and/or Prairie Ronde Twp and add more of Kalamazoo Twp.
If I was redistricting the Berrien seats, I'd make sure that Benton Harbor/Twp and Niles/Buchanan aren't together and that Benton/Twp and Lincon and Lake Twp's are together. I don't think New Buffalo has enough people to matter in the Benton's case, and the township breaks would allow Niles and BH to make that one a lean dem seat.
If I was the dems redistricter, I'd try and somehow get either Benton and Niles together, or take the Benton seat up to Covert and maybe South Haven. That would probably create two solid GOP seats (one Berrien and one Van Buren based), but probably give the dems one because Lincoln Twp and Royalton Twp is to the South. In the alternative, I'd take Niles and combine it was Dowagiac, Cassopolis, and Vandalia in Cass County. That will make that seat competitive, although not solidly dem.
As a Dem (but interested in all redistricting), I think that the map will be an incumbency protection plan. The question is, who gets voted off the island should all the incumbents win? McCotter would be my favorite choice, but given that metro Detroit has lost so much population my guess is that he would have to take the hit.
As far as the Kalamazoo seats, I'll get back to you at some Democratic thoughts on creating a new suburban Democratic district to replace the 61st.
PB - I've read your Grand Rapids stuff. It's good work, as much as I would like to disagree with it.
If you know where I can get the map software like you use, let me know. I'd like to add that to my county updates to go with the table numbers. I'd like to be able to point out locations for the townships only a local would know. (Meridian Township = Okemos/Haslett, Putnam Twp = Pinckney, etc.)
If we lose a seat (as I expect), I think McCotter will be running for senate is the incumbents are knocked out and split control. Rumor is that Stabenow is thinking about her 2012 opponent, and she does not want to face Rogers, who won her old district.
McCotter has the worst geographic neighbors. Southfield or Detroit to the East. The Wayne County Airport area (Dingell democrats) to the South/Southeast. Ypsi to the West/southwest and Livingston County (Mike Rogers home) to the west/Northwest. The only way it could go is North and not hurt McCotter getting the Rogers part of Oakland, forcing Rogers to take Washtenaw/Genesee,Eaton, Gratiot, and the rest of Shiawassee County. I don't think Schauer wants to give up his part of Washtenaw, so that would likely give Rogers Fenton, Grand Blanc, and Linden, making Kildee's district even more democrat and pushing it north/northwest.
My nightmare is carving out Livingston County like it was in the 80's (divided between Bob Carr in Lansing and William Broomfield in Oakland.
In a piece of trivia, I think Carr was one of the last three democrats to win in Livingston County. The others - Frank Kelley, and Richard Austin. 1990 I believe. (maybe 86 - Blanchard also won it then)
Don't sell short the Republicans in Kalamazoo County. It may typically go democrat at the federal and state level, but Land and Cox still won in 2006. Historically, it has been dominated by Republicans at the local level, at least outside the city. While the democrats have made some inroads in recent years, Republicans still hold the state senate seat, two of three state house seats, four of six county offices, and eight of seventeen county commission seats (it would be nine if one Republican had bothered to campaign).
While there is no question that the dems will target the senate seat, it would be a mild surpise if they made the 61st a top priority. In 2008, they threw everything (over half a million dollars) into the race and still lost. 2010 will be a better year than 2008. The dems have no credible candidate running, and Republicans have a top-quality candidate unlikely to face a highly contested primary.
A few thoughts on redistricting.
I suspect Upton wants to see his district change as little as possible. There is basically no chance he will lose to a democrat, and he has done pretty well in the city of Kalamazoo until the last two cycles. Substantially changing his district might make him vulnerable to a primary challenge.
If there is split control of redistricting (likely), what typically happens is an incumbent protection plan. If the state loses a district, what typically happens is a 'fair fight', where one incumbent of each party is put in the same district, which is drawn with as little lean as possible.
In 2012, the two Detroit seats will be protected by federal law, though they will have to expand further into the suburbs. This may make the current incumbents vulnerable to primary challenges if they don't retire or lose before then.
Stupak's seat will be safe due to geography. Other than that, everyone is vulnerable. A McCotter/Peters fight is possible, but the dynamics could change depending on who retires or loses before then.
It would be very hard to make the 61st district more democrat than it is now. The city of Kalamazoo can't be broken up. The eastern half of Kalamazoo Township is separated from the western half by the city. The only way to unite them would be a horseshoe around the north side of Kalamazoo, but that couldn't include Portage, which leaves the hypothetical 61st too small and not much that could be added to the 60th to make it the right size.
Republicans will probably try to move western K township to the 60th and Cooper to the 61st. The prelimiary census projections make the numbers for this look pretty good.
I have a few thoughts on making the 61st more Democratic. Given that Michigan's population was estimated as 10,003,422 in the 2008 ACS numbers, each house district needs to be between 86,393 and 95,487 people. If we keep Portage Township (44,897) as the base of the district, that leaves at least 41,496 more residents needed. Add Pavilion Township (5,829), Comstock Township (13,851), Galesburg (1,988), the eastern portion of Kalamazoo Township (which I've estimated at about 9,000), Cooper Township (8,754), and the eastern portion of Kalamazoo Township (just over 11,000) would make this district meet the population requirements and would give Obama 59% of the vote. A revised 60th District consisting of Kalamazoo City (77,145), Parchment (1,936) and Oshtemo (17,003) would also fit the state district guidelines and give Obama 72% of the vote. This would make the current 61st a much more Democratic district and keep the 60th in the Dem column as well.
I'm not trying to sell the Kalamazoo Republicans short. It's easy to be a Republican in my area. It's not as easy there, or in Washtenaw County. You've all kept Kalamazoo from turning into Washtenaw County lite (where they did almost everything right in 2004 and still got swept).
In the 8th right now, because of Michigan State's spreading influence, we're fighting in Southern Clinton County (which flipped to Obama). Bath and DeWitt Twps, which also affects the 85th District. In Ingham County, Meridian Twp's (Okemos) almost a lost cause now, about 7-10% consistently less than Oshtemo, which is its equivalent.
There's just some scary factors there, and near the universities overall, unless the bleeding is stopped. The good news is that the impressionable 20 somethings (that aren't political junkies which are the exception rather than the norm) are going to see that Obama is even less competent than Bush was when things aren't changing, much like Granholm is also doing right now. That's a start. The rest is up to candidates and their supporters to sell something with substance instead of trying to be cool, which is why I'd like to see something like Mike Pence run.
PB:
According to 2008 census estimates, your proposed 61st district would have about 110,000 people.
Post a Comment